Understanding the Series Calculation Problem

=====================================================

In this article, we will delve into a series calculation problem involving shifted values and recursive algorithms. The problem arises from using numpy.where to create a new column based on previous values in another column.

The given code initializes a series with zeros and attempts to use numpy.where to shift the value of one column based on the value of another column. However, it incorrectly evaluates the shifted value as a series of zeros due to the initial initialization of the series. This leads to an incorrect result, which can be seen in the provided example.

The Problem Statement

The problem statement is as follows:

• We have two columns: Alpha and Bravo.
• We want to create a new column, PositionLong, based on the values of Alpha and Bravo. Specifically, if the value in Alpha is 1, then the value in PositionLong should be 1. If the previous value in PositionLong is 1 and the current value in Bravo is also 1, then the value in PositionLong should be 1.
• However, using numpy.where to create a new column based on shifted values leads to an incorrect result.

Understanding numpy.where

numpy.where is a regular function that takes three arguments: two conditions and one value to return when both conditions are true. The syntax for numpy.where is as follows:

np.where(condition1, value_if_true, value_if_false)

In the provided code, np.where(df['Alpha'] == 1, 1, (np.where(np.logical_and(df['PositionLong'].shift(1) == 1, df['Bravo'] == 1), 1, 0))) is used to create a new column based on the values of Alpha. However, this usage of numpy.where leads to an incorrect result.

Understanding Shifted Values

Shifted values are created by using the .shift() method in pandas Series. The .shift() method shifts all elements down by one position and fills NaN at the end with the last element’s value. For example, if we have a series df['PositionLong'] = [1, 2, 3], then df['PositionLong'].shift(1) would return [NaN, 1, 2].

Recursive Algorithms

A recursive algorithm is an algorithm that calls itself to solve a problem. In this case, we want to create a new column based on the previous values in another column. This can be achieved using a recursive function.

Manual Loop Solution

One way to solve this problem is by using a manual loop. We can iterate over each row and check if the current value in Alpha is 1 or if the previous value in PositionLong is 1 and the current value in Bravo is also 1.

Numba Solution

However, iterating over each row manually can be expensive for large datasets. To efficiently implement a recursive algorithm, we can use Numba’s @njit decorator to create a just-in-time (JIT) compiler function.

Numba Implementation

from numba import njit

@njit
def rec_algo(alpha, bravo):
    res = np.empty(alpha.shape)
    res[0] = 1 if alpha[0] == 1 else 0
    for i in range(1, len(res)):
        if (alpha[i] == 1) or ((res[i-1] == 1) and bravo[i] == 1):
            res[i] = 1
        else:
            res[i] = 0
    return res

df['PositionLong'] = rec_algo(df['Alpha'].values, df['Bravo'].values).astype(int)

In this implementation, we use Numba’s @njit decorator to create a JIT compiler function. The function takes two arguments: alpha and bravo, which are the values of Alpha and Bravo respectively.

The function first initializes an empty array with the same shape as alpha. It then sets the value at index 0 to 1 if alpha[0] is equal to 1, otherwise it sets the value to 0. Finally, it iterates over each row starting from index 1 and checks if the current value in Alpha is 1 or if the previous value in PositionLong is 1 and the current value in Bravo is also 1.

If either condition is true, the function sets the value at the current index to 1. Otherwise, it sets the value to 0.

Result

The final result can be seen by printing the DataFrame:

print(df)

This will output the following DataFrame:

Conclusion

In this article, we explored a series calculation problem involving shifted values and recursive algorithms. We discussed the incorrect usage of numpy.where to create a new column based on shifted values and provided an explanation for why it leads to an incorrect result.

We also presented two solutions: one using a manual loop and another using Numba’s JIT compiler function. The latter is more efficient but requires knowledge of Numba and its decorators.

Last modified on 2024-08-23